Review and Giveaway: Rose Under Fire by Elizabeth Wein

September 13, 2013 4 - 4.5 Stars, Abuse, Elizabeth Wein, Get Ready To Cry, Giveaway, Historical Fiction, WWII Fiction 16 ★★★★

Rose Under Fire by Elizabeth Wein
Published by Disney Hyperion on September 10, 2013
Genres: Historical FIction
Pages: 368
Format: ARC
Source: BEA 2013
While flying an Allied fighter plane from Paris to England, American ATA pilot and amateur poet, Rose Justice, is captured by the Nazis and sent to Ravensbrück, the notorious women's concentration camp. Trapped in horrific circumstances, Rose finds hope in the impossible through the loyalty, bravery and friendship of her fellow prisoners. But will that be enough to endure the fate that’s in store for her?

Elizabeth Wein, author of the critically-acclaimed and best-selling Code Name Verity, delivers another stunning WWII thriller. The unforgettable story of Rose Justice is forged from heart-wrenching courage, resolve, and the slim, bright chance of survival.
I haven’t yet read Code Name Verity, Elizabeth Wein’s companion novel to Rose Under Fire, but now I absolutely must.  If you haven’t read CNV, then I’m sure you’ve at least heard the raves, and based on Wein’s writing in Rose Under Fire, the raves are warranted.

I feel like I have a decent knowledge of WWII, but I wasn’t aware that American women piloted planes for the Allies during the war.  Rose Justice, the fictional narrator of the story, feels so real, and it’s clear Wein meticulously researched the actual events that are woven into the story.  (I always read authors’ notes and acknowledgments, and in this case, it was very helpful because Wein details the facts versus the fiction in this book.)

Rose Justice is an American doing her part to support the Allies in the war against Germany.  When she was young, her father taught her to pilot planes, and she uses her skill to transport fighter planes in Europe.  During one of her missions, Nazi warplanes confront her in the sky and force her to land.  The Germans are startled when a young woman steps out of the plane, and while they treat her with a certain measure of respect, Rose is nevertheless sent to Ravensbruck, a concentration camp in Germany.  Rose experiences or witnesses every brutality doled out in the camps: gassing of prisoners, vicious beatings, sadistic medical experiments, and starvation.

Rose is housed with other non-Jewish prisoners, including a group of “Rabbits,” so named because of the awful “experiments” performed upon them.  These experiments were merely a form of torture designed to mutilate the Rabbits’ bodies.  Wein bluntly provides us with the details, and unfortunately, she did not have to make this up.  Rose is not subjected to these experiments, as they were reserved primarily for the Eastern European prisoners.  She does, however, suffer just about every other atrocity in the camp.

Rose Under Fire is a painful, difficult story to read, because we know the worst of the events described actually happened.  But Wein gives us reasons to feel a bit of hope and optimism, as well:

  • Rose survives Ravensbruck: This isn’t a spoiler since we learn this early on from the novel’s flashback/diary style.
  • Rose’s relationships with the Rabbits: Rozycka (Roza), in particular, forms a close bond with Rose.  Roza was crippled by the experiments done to her legs, but she remains fierce and brave, and she is my favorite character in the book.
  • The will of the prisoners to survive: During Rose’s imprisonment, she and the Rabbits rebel in ways both big and small, and they secretly support each other in ingenious ways.

The novel ends with the Nuremburg trials, and I think a part of me hoped for some cathartic sense of justice after everything Rose and the Rabbits endured, but really, no number of Nazis could possibly have been executed or punished to right the evil that was done.  So while there is no moral satisfaction, the story ends with some hope for Rose and the Rabbits who survived.

Note – I received an ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

Review posted at Goodreads.

And now for the really good stuff…

I’m giving away my SIGNED ARC of Rose Under Fire to a U.S. winner.  I got my copy at BEA this year, and Elizabeth Wein, by the way, was just lovely.  I say that based on the 30 second chat I had with her, but sometimes you just know.  Ya know?  The winner of the ARC will also receive a Hershey’s chocolate bar, and you’ll understand the reason for that when you read the book.

Elizabeth Wein at BEA

a Rafflecopter giveaway


16 Responses to “Review and Giveaway: Rose Under Fire by Elizabeth Wein”

  1. Annette Mills

    Here’s my take (if you are at all interested.) I absolutely loved Rose Under Fire and will post my review next week. It took everything I had to get through Code Name Verity. Didn’t get that one at all. Go figure….

  2. Sarah P

    I have a bit of trouble, yeah-it all just seems so surreal that it actually happened…my brain has trouble wrapping itself around that fact that such terrible things did occur.

  3. Caroline Waddell

    I find it difficult (especially as a Jew who knows her relatives lived through it), but also necessary. I am excited to read this book. Thanks for the chance to win!!

  4. That Girl Reads

    I haven’t read many historical fictions with concentration camps in them. After reading The Diary of Anne Frank back in middle school MANY years ago I’ve kept away from anything similar to that. But I’m willing to try this one.

  5. Kim

    I think that it is hard to read about concentration camps, but I often do it anyway. I don’t know what it is about sad books, but I read a lot of the. It is nice if it ends on a hopeful note, but so many stories about concentration camps don’t, so if it doesn’t — if it’s realistic like that — it could crush me for a while, but I’d understand. This book sounds really, really interesting.

  6. Dorothy Teel

    I enjoy reading about history and this is a book that I would like to read as it opens your minds as to what could of been and horrible it may have been.

  7. wendy-book-scents

    It’s hard to read, definitely, because I get really sad. That’s why the hope is so important because otherwise I would just be depressed. I’m really excited to read rose under fire — CNV was amazing and I know this will be too!

  8. Jessica Chiles

    It is a really tough subject, but I consider it very important to understand what the prisoners went through. I remember reading Night (a memoir) in high school and the book was so impactful I can still remember it to this day.

  9. Kristin H

    As odd as it sounds, I like reading about concentration camp experiences because it reminds me of the horrors that have happened to make sure they never happen again. Those books are always emotionally draining though and I need something fun to read afterwards.

  10. Cleo Li-Schwartz

    I really love World War II novels, but yes, it’s hard. On a somewhat related note, I’m reading a book about North Korea right now, and it’s one of those reads that are so gruesome and disturbing you want to put the book down, but as Kristin says, we have to be aware of these atrocities. And yes, after I finish Nothing to Envy, I’ll probably be looking for a light read.

  11. Cleo Li-Schwartz

    I really love World War II novels, but yes, it’s hard. On a somewhat related note, I’m reading a book about North Korea right now, and it’s one of those reads that are so gruesome and disturbing you want to put the book down, but as Kristin says, we have to be aware of these atrocities. And yes, after I finish Nothing to Envy, I’ll probably be looking for a light read.

  12. Jessica

    I love historical fiction, and one of the many that I loved was The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas, so it doesn’t bother me in that it prevents me from reading. Yes, it bothers me in real life (like the real events), and I’ll cry while reading, but.

    I’m really excited to read this. I’ve started Code Name Verity and have been loving it.

  13. Bookworm1858

    This book destroyed me-it was so intense and brought out so many emotions. That’s why I ended up preferring CNV, which I would say has a lighter story (though really what doesn’t have a lighter story than this?)

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge