Review: Crash Into You by Katie McGarry

November 17, 2013 Uncategorized 4 ★★½

Crash Into You by Katie McGarry
Series: Pushing the Limits # 3
Published by Harlequin Teen on November 26, 2013
Genres: Contemporary Romance
Pages: 474
Format: eARC
Source: Publisher
Goodreads
two-half-stars
The girl with straight As, designer clothes and the perfect life-that's who people expect Rachel Young to be.  So the private-school junior keeps secrets from her wealthy parents and overbearing brothers...and she's just added two more to the list.  One involves racing strangers down dark country roads in her Mustang GT.  The other?  Seventeen-year-old Isaiah Walker-a guy she has no business even talking to.  But when the foster kid with the tattoos and intense gray eyes comes to her rescue, she can't get him out of her mind.

Isaiah has secrets, too. About where he lives, and how he really feels about Rachel.  The last thing he needs is to get tangled up with a rich girl who wants to slum it on the south side for kicks-no matter how angelic she might look.

But when their shared love of street racing puts both their lives in jeopardy, they have six weeks to come up with a way out.  Six weeks to discover just how far they'll go to save each other.

Even though my rating for Crash Into You isn’t great, and even though it’s my least favorite of the Pushing the Limits series, I would still recommend it to fans of NA-ish contemporary romance.  I, however, have grown tired of the glut of controlling and sometimes violent behavior exhibited by the male characters in this genre.  To be clear, Crash Into You doesn’t come close to glorifying this behavior as books like Hopeless and Ten Tiny Breaths do.  But still, I was turned off by the overt possessiveness that Isaiah felt towards Rachel immediately after meeting her and throughout the story.  There was a lot of fist clenching going on here, as well as barely restrained urges to fight whenever Isaiah gets a hint that Rachel is paying attention to someone else, even when she is merely being polite.  None of this is helped by the fact that Rachel is portrayed in an overly juvenile way, with lots of peeking out from under her hair, staring at the ground, biting of her lip, numerous mentions of how “tiny” she is, etc.

Much of this book, following the initial googly-eyed meeting of Isaiah and Rachel, had a version of the following dialogue:

Isaiah: “You’re too good for me.”
Rachel: “I’m too inexperienced for you.”
Both: “I love you.”
Isaiah: “I’m going to hurt you.”
Rachel: “Only I can fix you.”
Isaiah: “I must protect you.”

I kept waiting for a big, dumb misunderstanding that some authors rely on to create drama, but we are thankfully spared that.  It’s almost as though the author took the worst aspects of New Adult and dialed them way back.  But not all the way, unfortunately.  We’ve got the requisite damaged characters, although they don’t come close to the level of messed-up-ness as the horrible characters in the books I mentioned above.  Isaiah is a foster kid who’s had some rotten breaks throughout his life, but he’s relatively well-adjusted.  And even though his tendency to control is unappealing, he never crosses the line into abuse and stalking.  Rachel had a very different upbringing: perfect on the surface, with wealthy, loving parents.  But she’s a shadow of the older sister who died before Rachel was born.  Her sometimes meek personality was molded by her parents who had her in an attempt to replace their first-born daughter .  Through her life, Rachel felt that she could never live up to the memory of her sister.  The relationship between the two has many sweet moments, but the drama seemed forced at times.

It was nice to see the main characters from the earlier PTL books make an appearance.  The e-ARC also included the first two chapters of the next book, Take Me On.  I wasn’t thrilled to see that this story starts with a fistfight, but the MC seems to be a bit more fun-loving than Isaiah, and I’m hoping that I’ll have better luck with that one.

 

Stephanie

4 Responses to “Review: Crash Into You by Katie McGarry”

  1. Tiffany

    I am SOOOOO glad you feel that way. Sometimes my sister recommends these types of books to me and I wonder how she can read a book about someone so possessive and controlling and not see an issue. Outside of that fact, it may be a good book, but I have a hard time with the issue. I haven’t read this particular book, but it was a trend I was beginning to think no one else was noticing.
    Tiffany recently posted…Making Up For Monday: $30 to spendMy Profile

  2. Maggie @ Just a Couple More Pages

    This is my least favorite in the series, too, although for different reasons. I didn’t mind Isiah’s behavior, I thought at times it was ridiculous, but I really liked Rachel and I thought she had a real inner strength and maybe that’s why I didn’t pick up on what Isiah was doing? My issue was all the freaking drama. The bad guy wanting $5000 from them and the car racing and the brother having a gambling problem. It was just too over the top for me and, now that I heard you use the word forced to describe it, maybe that’s another issue I have with it.
    Maggie @ Just a Couple More Pages recently posted…Book Review: Catching JordanMy Profile

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge