Review: Wicked Little Secrets by Kara Taylor

March 11, 2014 Reviews 4 ★★★★

Wicked Little Secrets by Kara Taylor
Series: Prep School Confidential # 2
Published by St. Martin's Griffin on March 4, 2014
Genres: Mystery
Pages: 304
Format: ARC
Source: Publisher
Anne Dowling becomes entangled in a web of secrets involving a missing student and a conspiracy at Wheatley Prep in this fast-paced, juicy follow-up to Prep School Confidential

Anne Dowling—a fresh, original, and funny new YA heroine whose knowing, irreverent voice will remind readers of Pretty Little Liars and Private—is back for her second semester at Wheatley Prep. Although things have settled (somewhat) since her roommate Isabella’s death, Anne's still kind of obsessed with the disappearance of Wheatley student Matthew Weaver thirty years ago, since she found a picture of him and his crewmates with the words “they killed him” scrawled on the back among Isabella’s things.

When Anne learns that her boyfriend Brent’s dad is one of the now-powerful Wheatley alumni who rowed crew with Matthew, and that the crew team continues to induct new members with a creepy-sounding ritual called “The Drop,” she knows further investigation could put her relationship with Brent in danger. Determined to discover the truth, she reaches out to Anthony, Isabella’s townie brother, who helps her delve deeper into the secrets in Wheatley’s past. Secrets someone would kill to keep hidden. As the school’s Spring Formal—and its notorious afterparty—approaches, Anne sees the perfect opportunity to do some off-campus digging into the lives of Wheatley’s VIPs in this thrilling, unputdownable read—but if she’s not careful, she’ll be the next student who never comes back.

Prep School Confidential, the first book in this series and the first book by Kara Taylor, was such a fun and dark surprise.  Fun because of Anne, the unforgettable narrator, and dark because the cute cover gave no hints of the evil that awaited Anne at her new boarding school.  When her roommate, Isabella, was murdered, Anne made it her mission to unmask the murderer and those responsible for the resulting cover-up.  When Prep School Confidential ended, Anne had discovered a much older and completely unrelated conspiracy that she becomes just as determined to solve.  In Wicked Little Secrets, Anne investigates the death of a former student, Matthew Weaver, who had ties to the parents of several of her classmates, including her boyfriend.

I was a bit worried that the mystery of Matthew’s death would be less intriguing than Isabella’s death, since it lacked the same sense of urgency and the connection to Anne.  But as Anne pushes on, the mystery wraps up more and more of Anne’s classmates, and the danger comes closer to Anne as she gets closer to figuring out whodunit.

There is a love triangle in Wicked Little Secrets, but…wait for it!…it is handled perfectly.  Brent is Anne’s classmate and boyfriend, and Anthony is Isabella’s brother with whom she also shares a strong attraction.  Both of the relationships feel so real.  Neither guy is the ridiculously unbelievable “I’d die for you, and I’ll kill myself if I can’t have you,” type that is found all too often in YA love triangles.  I hesitate to even call it a love triangle because that term brings to my mind things like weeping hysteria and collapsing to the floor with grief after a minor tiff.  (You’ll have to excuse me, because my last review was for Ignite Me, so this nonsense is way too fresh in my mind.)  But all of that is absent here.  Yes, Anne quarrels with both Brent and Anthony.  Yes, she cries.  But they all behave like typical teenagers who have identities separate from their romance, and it is not the focal point of the story around which everything else revolves.  I cannot adequately express how refreshing this is, and I’d even go so far to say that this is reason alone to read the book.

Anne is one of the most memorable female protagonists I’ve come across in a long time.  She’s forceful without being obnoxious.  She can be careless and reckless and frustrating, but her heart is in the right place.  And she does NOT give up.  She’s the kind of girl I would have loved to have been friends with when I was a teenager, even while I was wishing that I could be a little bit more like her.

You can also check out:

Note: I received an ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.


4 Responses to “Review: Wicked Little Secrets by Kara Taylor”

  1. Kristen@My Friends Are Fiction

    So happy you enjoyed this one since you liked book 1 so much. I’ve not read this series–and it wouldn’t even be on my radar if it weren’t for you. The covers are not something I’d be drawn to since they look pretty light and young. I imagine an accurate depiction of a teen girl was refreshing after your Shatter Me series read, haha.
    Kristen@My Friends Are Fiction recently posted…Comment on Review of Don’t Look Back by Jennifer Armentrout by Jessica @ Rabid ReadsMy Profile

    • Stephanie

      I hope you will give this a shot sometime, even though I know this isn’t your genre. You might be pleasantly surprised.

      I agree about the covers. I don’t think they’re accurate depictions of the tone of the story. I think a different design could capture a larger audience.

  2. Michelle (Pink Polka Dot Book Blog)

    I liked book 1, but haven’t decided if I’ll continue on or not. I loved the mystery in book 1, but didn’t love Anne that much (she was a little insensitive and judgmental at times). I also really liked Isabella and was sad that she was killed off so early! But the mystery of it was fun and the mystery in book 2 sounds interesting too!
    Michelle (Pink Polka Dot Book Blog) recently posted…Cover Lover (or Hater)- November EditionMy Profile

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge